Tabula Debate

Speeches, order and times

6 min read · Beginner

A policy round has eight speeches. Each of the four debaters gives two. The first four speeches are constructives, where teams build their arguments. The last four are rebuttals, where teams answer, pick their best arguments and explain why they win. After each constructive, the other team asks questions for three minutes. This is cross-examination. Each team also has a set amount of prep time (planning time) to use between speeches.

On this page

The order and the common times

This is the common national high school format. "Aff" (affirmative) is the team for the plan. "Neg" (negative) is the team against it. "1st aff" means the aff's first speaker.

Local leagues can use different times. For example, a state league or a novice division may change the rebuttal length or the prep time. Always check the tournament's rules.

#SpeechWho speaksTime
11AC: first affirmative constructive1st aff8 min
Cross-ex of the 1AC2nd neg asks, 1st aff answers3 min
21NC: first negative constructive1st neg8 min
Cross-ex of the 1NC1st aff asks, 1st neg answers3 min
32AC: second affirmative constructive2nd aff8 min
Cross-ex of the 2AC1st neg asks, 2nd aff answers3 min
42NC: second negative constructive2nd neg8 min
Cross-ex of the 2NC2nd aff asks, 2nd neg answers3 min
51NR: first negative rebuttal1st neg5 min
61AR: first affirmative rebuttal1st aff5 min
72NR: second negative rebuttal2nd neg5 min
82AR: second affirmative rebuttal2nd aff5 min

Prep time: each team gets a set total for the whole round. 8 or 10 minutes is common. See Prep time.

Who asks in cross-ex: usually, the debater who is not about to speak asks the questions. That way, the next speaker can prepare. Some leagues allow "open cross-ex," where both partners can ask or answer. Check the rules.

What each speech should do

1AC: first affirmative constructive

The 1AC is mostly written before the round. It reads the plan (the change the aff wants) and the advantages (reasons the plan is good), with evidence. It should show the stock issues, the aff's basic jobs: there is a problem (harms), the world now does not fix it (inherency), and the plan does (solvency). See The affirmative case.

1NC: first negative constructive

The 1NC brings the neg's arguments. Each big argument gets its own sheet (a page of notes). There are two kinds:

  • Off-case arguments start on new sheets. They include topicality (the plan does not fit the topic), disadvantages (the plan causes harm), counterplans (a better plan) and kritiks (the ideas behind the plan are wrong).
  • On-case arguments answer the 1AC directly, on the case sheet.

The 1NC usually starts with a roadmap, the order it will go in: "Three off, then case." That means three off-case arguments, then answers on the case.

2AC: second affirmative constructive

The 2AC answers every neg argument from the 1NC. It also extends the case: it carries the aff's arguments forward. This speech has a lot to cover in 8 minutes. Teams often bring pre-written answers, called blocks or frontlines.

2NC and 1NR: the negative block

These two speeches come back to back, with only a cross-ex between them. Together they are called the negative block: 13 minutes of neg speaking. The partners split the arguments. For example, the 2NC takes the counterplan and the DA (disadvantage), and the 1NR takes topicality and case. They should not both answer the same arguments.

1AR: first affirmative rebuttal

The 1AR has 5 minutes to answer 13 minutes of the block. It must be efficient. It extends the aff's best answers on each sheet, and keeps the case alive. An argument the 1AR drops (does not answer) is usually lost for the aff.

2NR: second negative rebuttal

The 2NR is the neg's last speech. It should choose. Most good 2NRs go for one or two arguments, not everything. It explains why those arguments win, and why they outweigh the case. New arguments are not allowed here, except to answer new things from the 1AR.

2AR: second affirmative rebuttal

The 2AR is the last speech of the round. It answers the 2NR, extends the aff's best path to winning, and tells the judge how to weigh. It can answer the 2NR with new explanation, and it extends what the 1AR said. It cannot add brand-new arguments.

Speech names in short

You will see these names on flows and ballots:

ShortLong
1AC, 2ACfirst and second affirmative constructive
1NC, 2NCfirst and second negative constructive
1NR, 2NRfirst and second negative rebuttal
1AR, 2ARfirst and second affirmative rebuttal
CXcross-examination
the blockthe 2NC and 1NR together

Example in flow shorthand

One topicality argument, followed through every speech that touches it. Topicality (T) says the plan does not fit the topic.

Key:

  • Int (interpretation): the neg's meaning of a topic word. >= means "at least."
  • Vio (violation): how the plan breaks that meaning.
  • Stds (standards): reasons the meaning is better. Limits means it keeps the topic small enough.
  • We meet: the plan fits their meaning anyway.
  • CI (counter-interpretation): the aff's own meaning.
  • Reasonable (reasonability): the plan is close enough to the topic.
  • Core aff: a plan at the heart of the topic.
  • Ext = extend. yr = year. > = outweighs.
1NC
  T: "substantial"
  Int: >= 10%
  Vio: plan = 2%
  Stds: limits
2AC
  1. We meet
  2. CI: "real importance"
  3. Reasonable
2NC
  No we meet: plan is 2%
  CI: no limit
  Limits > all
1AR
  Ext we meet: plan is 12%
    by yr 2
  Reasonable
2NR
  Go for T only. Plan is 2%
    at start; CI = no limit;
    vote neg
2AR
  We meet: plan is 12% once
    in place. Reasonability:
    core aff

How to read it: the 2NC took T in the block, so the 1NR did not touch it. The 2NR chose to go for T alone. The 2AR extended "we meet" and reasonability, which the 1AR had made. It added nothing new.

Common mistakes

  • The 2AC drops an off-case argument. Fix: answer every 1NC sheet in the 2AC, even briefly. A dropped argument is hard to bring back.
  • The block partners answer the same arguments. Fix: split the sheets before the 2NC. Say the split out loud in the 2NC roadmap.
  • The 2NR goes for everything. Fix: pick one or two winning arguments and explain them well.
  • The 2AR makes brand-new arguments. Fix: extend what the 1AR said, and answer the 2NR. Most judges ignore brand-new 2AR arguments.
  • The 1AR spends too long on one sheet. Fix: plan your time per sheet before you stand up, and keep to it.
  • Judges mix up who asks in cross-ex. Fix: the debater who does not speak next usually asks. If unsure, follow the tournament's rules.