Kritiks (K)
Most negative arguments ask, "Is the plan a good idea?" A kritik, or K, asks a different question: "Are the ideas behind the plan a good way to think?" It says the affirmative relies on a harmful way of seeing the world. It shows what that way of thinking leads to, and it offers a different approach. The word comes from the German word for "critique." A kritik can be about the plan, about the affirmative's reasons, or about the words it used.
On this page
What a kritik does
A disadvantage (DA) says the plan causes something bad. A kritik says the aff's starting point is the problem. For example, a kritik might argue:
- the aff describes some groups of people as threats, and that way of describing people causes harm;
- the aff assumes a certain economic system is natural, and that assumption hides who that system hurts;
- the aff uses a word or a frame that does damage, no matter what the plan does.
Kritiks draw on ideas from philosophy, politics, history and the social sciences. Many debaters find them some of the most interesting arguments in debate. Some judges prefer them; some are skeptical. Both are common views.
The parts
The neg reads a kritik in the 1NC, its first speech. There it usually has three core parts. The debate around it adds two more.
| Part | The question it answers |
|---|---|
| Link | What does the aff do, say or assume that the kritik criticizes? |
| Impact | Why is that way of thinking harmful? |
| Alternative | What should we do or think instead? |
| Framework | How should the judge decide this round? Weigh the plan's results, or the aff's ideas, or both? |
| Role of the ballot | What is the judge's vote for? |
Link
The link shows that the aff is part of the problem. Links can come from:
- the plan (what it does),
- the advantages (the reasons and evidence the aff uses),
- the words the aff used,
- the assumptions under the aff's argument.
Specific links are stronger. "Your second advantage describes this region as a danger that must be controlled" is better than "all policies do this."
Impact
The impact explains what the harmful way of thinking leads to. Some kritik impacts are about real-world results (violence, exclusion, a cycle of conflict). Some are about the debate itself (what we learn, and what this round teaches). Some kritiks also argue that the aff's own advantages will fail, because they rest on a flawed idea. This is often called "the K turns the case." See Turns case.
Alternative
The alternative ("alt") is what the neg offers instead. It can be:
- a different way of thinking about the problem;
- a call to reject the aff's frame;
- a different action, by a different actor.
The alt is often the hardest part of a kritik to explain. Good neg teams say clearly what the alt does and how it solves, or at least avoids, the impact.
Some neg teams go for a kritik without the alternative, as a reason the aff's way of thinking should not be rewarded. Teams and judges disagree on whether that is enough.
Framework
Framework is the debate about how the judge should decide. The aff often argues: "The judge should weigh the plan's results against the neg's best policy option." The neg often argues: "The judge should first ask whether the aff's ideas are sound, because ideas shape what policies do."
Framework is often where a K round is won or lost. See Framework against a kritik.
Role of the ballot
The role of the ballot (ROB) is a short claim about what the judge's vote means. For example: "The ballot should go to the team that best challenges harmful ways of thinking." Or: "The ballot should go to the team with the best policy." A related idea is the role of the judge: "The judge is a policymaker," or "The judge is an educator." See Role of the ballot.
How to answer a kritik (for the aff)
The aff first answers the K in the 2AC, its second speech. A full 2AC answer often has:
- Framework: the judge should weigh the plan's results, and the neg must offer a competing policy.
- Perm (permutation): the aff can do the plan and the alternative together. See Permutations.
- No link or link defense: the aff does not do what the K says, or the link is too general.
- Case outweighs: the aff's advantages are larger and more certain than the K's impact.
- Alt fails: the alternative does not solve, or is too vague to evaluate.
- Impact turn: in some debates, the aff argues that the idea the K criticizes is actually good. This is risky but possible, and the aff must defend it with care.
How to judge a kritik
A kritik can feel new to a parent judge. These steps help:
- Start with framework. Which way of deciding did each team argue for? Who won that debate? This tells you what counts.
- Then the link. Did the neg show that this aff does the thing the K criticizes? A K with no link should not win.
- Then the impact and the alternative. What harm does the K show? What does the alt offer, and does it solve that harm?
- Then the perm. Can the aff do both the plan and the alt? If yes, the K is not a reason to reject the plan, unless the neg shows why doing both fails.
- Weigh. Compare the K's impact (with the alt) to the aff's advantages, using the framework that won.
You do not need to know the authors or the philosophy behind the K. Judge it like any other argument: decide on what was explained, not on what you already know.
Some affirmatives are critical too. See Kritikal affirmatives. For a fair summary of the kritik families debaters read most, see Common kritik families.
Example in flow shorthand
A generic security kritik against an aff whose advantage says a rival country is a threat that must be contained.
The 1NC is the neg's first speech, and the 2AC is the aff's answer. The 2NR and 2AR are each team's last speech. Shorthand: L = link, I = impact, FW = framework, adv = advantage, "->" = "leads to", w/o = without. Names in parentheses, like (Scholar 19), are invented evidence authors and years.
1NC
K: Security
L: adv 2 calls rival a
"threat" to be controlled
(Theorist)
I: threat talk -> cycle
of conflict (Scholar 19)
Alt: reject the threat frame
2AC
1. FW: weigh plan vs a
policy alt
2. Perm: do the plan, and
drop adv 2's threat
framing
3. Alt fails: no concrete
action
4. Case outweighs
2NR
FW: ideas shape policy;
weigh framing first
Perm fails: adv 2 still
needs the threat to matter
Alt = new way to see rival
-> less conflict
K turns case: threat talk
makes adv fail
2AR
FW: "ideas shape policy"
has no card; plan first
Perm solves: the plan works
w/o adv 2's framing
Alt is vague; case is
concrete
Case still wins under any FW
How to read it: the round turns on framework and the perm. If the judge weighs only the plan's results, the aff is ahead. If the judge weighs the aff's framing first, the neg is ahead, unless the perm solves. The perm fight is about whether the plan still works once the threat framing is dropped. A good RFD would say which framework won, and why.
Common mistakes
- Neg: a link to "all policies." Fix: quote or describe what this aff does. Specific links beat generic ones.
- Neg: an alternative no one can explain. Fix: say in one or two plain sentences what the alt does and why it solves.
- Neg: ignoring the aff's case. Fix: explain why the K turns the case, or why the case does not matter under your framework.
- Aff: answering only with framework. Fix: also make a perm and answer the link. If you lose framework with nothing else, you lose the round.
- Aff: a perm with no explanation. Fix: say what the perm looks like, and why doing both is better than the alt alone.
- Judges: deciding on how they feel about kritiks in general. Fix: decide the framework debate as argued, then apply it.
Related pages
- The kritik link: what makes a link specific and strong.
- The alternative: how alts work, and how to answer them.
- Role of the ballot: what the judge's vote stands for.
- Framework against a kritik: the aff's main answer, in depth.
- Answering a kritik: a full 2AC block.
- Impact calculus: how to weigh a K against the case.