Internal links (IL)
An internal link is a step in the middle of an argument. It explains how the first thing leads to the last thing. For example: "The plan costs money" leads to "other programs get cut," which leads to "students lose help." The middle step is the internal link. Every step is a place where the argument can break, so a long chain of weak steps is less likely to happen.
On this page
What an internal link is
Most debate arguments are chains. They start with something the plan does, and end with a harm or a benefit. The internal link (IL) is any step between the start and the end.
Internal links show up on both sides of the round:
- In a disadvantage (DA), the neg's argument that the plan causes harm, the internal link connects the link to the impact. See Disadvantages.
- In an advantage, the aff's argument that the plan does good, the internal link connects the plan's effect to the impact. See Advantages and internal links.
The idea is the same in both. This page covers both.
Chains with more than one step
Some arguments have one internal link. Many have several.
| Step | DA example (generic) | Advantage example (generic) |
|---|---|---|
| Start (link or plan effect) | The plan costs $50B | The plan replaces old water pipes |
| Internal link 1 | The new cost forces cuts | Less lead gets into tap water |
| Internal link 2 | Cuts fall on school programs | Fewer children are exposed to lead |
| End (impact) | Students lose help | Children's health and learning improve |
Each step needs a reason, and often evidence. A step with no reason is a gap. The other team can point to the gap and say, "No internal link."
Why long chains lose strength
Every step has some chance of being wrong. When steps stack, the chances multiply.
Here is a simple way to see it. Suppose each step is 80% likely. With one step, the chain is 80% likely. With four steps, it is about 41% likely (0.8 × 0.8 × 0.8 × 0.8). With eight steps, it is under 17%.
Real rounds do not use exact numbers. But the idea helps. A short, strong chain can beat a long chain with a huge impact. That is a probability argument. See Impact calculus.
Some judges are wary of long chains that end in very large impacts. Others accept them if each step has good evidence and the other team does not answer it. Both views are common. Teams should argue it, not assume it.
How to answer an internal link
These answers work against a DA or an advantage.
- No internal link: the step does not follow. "New costs do not force cuts. The government can borrow."
- Missing step: the other team skipped a step. Name it. "They never explain why cuts would fall on schools."
- Alternate cause: something else causes the impact, so the plan cannot fix it alone. This is common against advantages. "Old paint causes more lead exposure than pipes do."
- Weak evidence: the card for this step does not say what the tag claims, or is about a different case. See Evidence and cards.
These answers defend an internal link.
- Read evidence for the step. Explain the reason, not just the claim.
- Answer the alternate cause: "Our cause is the largest one" or "Any cut in the harm still helps."
- Short-circuit the chain: show a quicker path from start to impact, with fewer steps.
Internal links and turns case
A turns case argument says one team's impact makes the other team's impact worse. It often works through an internal link. For example: "The DA causes a recession. A recession cuts the funding the plan needs. So the DA turns the case." The argument depends on that middle step. See Turns case.
How to judge internal links
- Read the chain one step at a time. Ask whether each step has a reason.
- Check for drops. If a team did not answer an internal link, it usually stands, if it came with a reason.
- Think about the whole chain's chance. Many weak steps make the impact less likely, if the teams argue that.
- Be careful about filling gaps yourself. If a team skipped a step and the other team pointed it out, many judges do not supply the missing step for them.
Example in flow shorthand
A generic advantage about clean water, on the case sheet (the flow page for the aff's case). Each part shows the speeches that argue it, top to bottom.
Key: -> = leads to. Adv = advantage. Alt cause = alternate cause. Ext = extend (carry forward). Names in parentheses are invented authors.
ADV: HEALTH
INTERNAL LINK
1AC: Lead pipes -> lead in
water (Analyst 21)
1NC: 1. Alt cause: old paint
is a bigger source
2AC: Pipes are top source in
city homes (Expert 22)
2NR: Ext alt cause: plan
can't fix paint
2AR: Plan cuts the pipe share;
any cut helps
IMPACT
1AC: Lead harms kids' learning
1NC: 2. No impact: levels
already falling
2AC: Falling, not safe
(Expert 22)
2NR: (no new answer)
How to read it: the 2NR gives no new answer on the impact, so it stands. The fight is the alternate cause. The judge decides how much of the harm the plan's pipes cause.
Common mistakes
- Both: skipping the internal link. Fix: say every step out loud. "Plan costs money, so the law forces cuts, so programs lose funding."
- Neg: only answering the impact. Fix: look for the weakest step in the middle. One broken step breaks the chain.
- Aff: ignoring an alternate cause. Fix: explain why your cause is big enough that solving it still matters.
- Both: a card that does not match the step. Fix: read each internal link card for what it actually says.
- Judges: filling in a missing step. Fix: a judge who follows the flow closely treats a gap that was pointed out and not answered as a missing step.
Related pages
- Disadvantages: where the internal link sits in a DA.
- Advantages and internal links: how an aff chain is built.
- Links and link turns: the step before the internal link.
- Impacts: the end of the chain.
- Turns case: how an internal link can flip an impact.
- Impact calculus: how chain length affects probability.